Skip to content

How can Kirk Cousins ‘win’ a Redskins QB competition that never happened?

Aug 24, 2014, 9:44 AM EDT


Joe Theismann made some comments on the Redskins’ quarterback situation during the TV broadcast of the Redskins-Ravens preseason game last night. In case you didn’t catch them, here is the key part.

“It’s going to be a decision that Jay Gruden is going to have to make,” Theismann said. “Right now, Robert Griffin III is his quarterback. Now, if there was a quarterback competition, it wouldn’t be a competition. Kirk Cousins would be the man I believe he would have to go to, because of the efficiency with which he has run (the offense).”

Well, maybe Joe, but here’s the thing. There wasn’t a quarterback competition. If there had been a quarterback competition then Cousins would have been in the game last night with some reps against Terrell Suggs, Haloti Ngata, Chri Canty, and other front-line Ravens defenders. As it was, those starters and the Ravens’ other front-line players were in there and made life difficult for Griffin. They were gone when Cousins came into the game early in the third quarter.

And Griffin would have had his shots against the likes of Pernell McPhee, DeAngelo Tyson, and Kapron Lewis-Moore.

Had there been a competition then Cousins would have taken first-team reps in training camp against Ryan Kerrigan, Brian Orakpo, DeAngelo Hall, and the rest of the defensive starters. He didn’t. And when the Patriots were in town, Cousins would have gone up against Darrell Revis, Brandon Browner, and Vince Wilfork. And Griffin would have had snaps against the Patriots backups.

Now let’s look at the other side the coin. Had there been a QB competition then Cousins would have played last night with Trent Williams at left tackle and he would have been throwing to Jordan Reed, Pierre Garçon, and DeSean Jackson last night. Griffin would have had some snaps with Tom Compton at left tackle and with Ryan Grant, Logan Paulsen, and Santana Moss as his primary pass targets.

We can debate all day who might have looked better surrounded by that talent and with those defensive matchup. However, the debate would be pointless. We have no way of knowing.

It makes no sense for Theismann to say that Kirk Cousins “won” the quarterback “competition” because there wasn’t one. It also would be illogical to say that Griffin would have “won”. We have no idea how it would have played out if Jay Gruden had conducted a competition. It’s just hypothetical.

The reality here and now is that it’s too late to have a QB competition even if Gruden was inclined to have one (and he’s not). How about if we deal with actual events instead of creating a phony QB controversy?

Latest Posts
  1. Examining Redskins’ RG3’s passing under pressure

    May 22, 2015, 10:00 AM EDT

    RG3-vs-NYG

    The Redskins are taking some steps to try to help Robert Griffin III succeed at quarterback. —They spent their top draft pick on a new right tackle, Brandon Scherff, to help plug up the leaky offensive line. —They are going to emphasize power running more, hoping to put Griffin in more favorable down and distance…

  2. Need to Know: Five offensive players with work to do during Redskins OTAs

    May 22, 2015, 5:00 AM EDT

    Ryan-grant-camp

    Here is what you need to know on this Friday, May 22, four days before the Washington Redskins start OTAs. Nickel coverage OTAs get underway on Tuesday at Redskins Park. Here are five offensive players who will have a lot at stake during this phase of the offseason. —G Chris Chester—He had Spencer Long breathing…

  3. Need to Know: What is the main reason for Redskins fans to be optimistic about 2015?

    May 21, 2015, 5:12 AM EDT

    Bill-Callahan-2

    Here is what you need to know on this Thursday, May 21, five days before the Redskins start OTAs. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page, or in the comments section…

  4. How many players are locks to make the Redskins’ 53?

    May 20, 2015, 1:29 PM EDT

    Redskins-camp-stretching

    The Redskins have the league maximum 90 players on their roster and a lot of what goes on between now and the start of the season will be about finding out who will be on the final 53-man roster. There is plenty of talk from Jay Gruden and Scot McCloughan about competition. But how much…

  5. Need to Know: Looking ahead–Who are the Redskins’ priority 2016 free agents?

    May 20, 2015, 5:34 AM EDT

    Keenan-Robinson-vs-Cowboys

    Here is what you need to know on this Wednesday, May 20, six days before the Redskins start OTAs. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page, or in the comments section…

  6. Unofficial Redskins 2015 depth chart, pre-OTAs

    May 19, 2015, 1:37 PM EDT

    1-on-1-camp

    Now that the Redskins have settled their 90-man roster, at least for the time being, here’s a look at the very unofficial team depth chart. The team currently has 44 offensive players, 42 defensive players and four specialists. Players in bold are starters. The players below the dotted line are undrafted players or others that…

  7. What does Ryan Tannehill’s extension mean for the Redskins’ RG3?

    May 19, 2015, 9:20 AM EDT

    RG3-passing-pocket-Eagles-2014

    Ryan Tannehill of the Dolphins became the first of the quarterbacks who came out in the 2012 draft to sign a contract extension yesterday. The Redskins have one of those quarterbacks in Robert Griffin III. What effect will Tannehill’s deal have on Griffin? First let’s look at the money. Tannehill was already under contract for…

  8. Need to Know: Who could be a surprise starter for the 2015 Redskins?

    May 19, 2015, 5:04 AM EDT

    Will-Compton-vs-Eagles

    Here is what you need to know on this Tuesday, May 19, 72 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page,…

  9. Need to Know: What has to happen for the Redskins to go run heavy on offense

    May 18, 2015, 5:11 AM EDT

    Morris-vs-Cowboys-2

    Here is what you need to know on this Monday, May 18, 73 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page,…

  10. Need to Know: Gruden, Redskins may not get 4th QB for camp

    May 17, 2015, 4:58 AM EDT

    Neyer-rookie-camp

    Here is what you need to know on this Sunday, May 17, 74 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Nickel coverage Five notes and quotes from rookie minicamp on Saturday: —Gruden believes that there is no pressing need to find a fourth quarterback after rookie free agent Connor Halliday decided to give…

  11. Redskins rookie camp practice report–afternoon session

    May 16, 2015, 5:51 PM EDT

    Rookie camp huddle

    The Redskins finished up the open portion of their 2015 rookie camp under mostly cloudy skies in Ashburn. In my report from this morning’s session I focused primarily on the offense. Here is a look at their afternoon session (which was shortened somewhat by impending storms) with a focus on the defense. —Kyshoen Jarrett lined…

  12. Redskins rookie camp practice report–AM session

    May 16, 2015, 1:24 PM EDT

    Kouandjio Scherff rookie camp

    A band of some 65 players wearing Redskins helmets and consisting of draft picks, undrafted free agents, tryout players and a few first-year players took to the practice field at Redskins Park on Saturday for the second day of rookie minicamp. Here are some observations, most on the offensive side of the ball. I’ll take…

  13. List of Redskins rookie camp tryout players

    May 16, 2015, 7:02 AM EDT

    Blake-Sims

    Here is the list of 35 players who are participating in the Redskins’ rookie camp on a tryout basis: QB Hutson Mason, Georgia P Kyle Martens, Rice P Keith Kostol, Oregon State K Corey Acosta, Southern Miss QB Anthony Heyer, USC CB Le’Vander Liggins, Louisiana Tech CB Tajh Hasson, UNLV CB Donovan Warren, Michigan S…

  14. Need to Know: Five things to watch during Redskins rookie camp

    May 16, 2015, 5:36 AM EDT

    Redskins-camp-battle

    Here is what you need to know on this Saturday, May 16, 75 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Nickel coverage Here are five things I’ll be looking for at today’s rookie camp at Redskins Park. The top picks—It’s hard tell much about linemen in a no-pads practice session but…

  15. Way too early Redskins 53-man roster projection–Defense

    May 15, 2015, 11:20 AM EDT

    Keenan-Robinson-back

    The Redskins will hold their first major on-field activity of their preseason program today when they start their rookie camp in Ashburn. That’s too early to predict who will make the 53-man roster when all of the preseason activity is done and the final cuts are made on September 5. But that won’t stop me.…

  16. Need to Know: Where do the Redskins still have needs?

    May 15, 2015, 5:47 AM EDT

    Redskins-minicamp-camp-2

    Here is what you need to know on this Friday, May 15, 76 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page,…

  17. Way too early Redskins 53-man roster projection–Offense

    May 14, 2015, 9:20 AM EDT

    Redskins-huddle-offense-camp

    The Redskins will hold their first major on-field activity of their preseason program tomorrow when they start their rookie camp in Ashburn. That’s too early to predict who will make the 53-man roster when all of the preseason activity is done and the final cuts are made on September 5. But that won’t stop me.…

  18. Need to Know: How do the Redskins stack up in the NFC East?

    May 14, 2015, 5:42 AM EDT

    Redskins-Cowboys-lines

    Here is what you need to know on this Thursday, May 14, 77 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Question of the day A few days a week I’ll give an in-depth answer to a question submitted by a fan on my Twitter feed, via the Real Redskins Facebook page,…

  19. Will the Redskins go to running back by committee?

    May 13, 2015, 2:00 PM EDT

    Morris-Jones-Redd-Thompson

    The Redskins’ ranked 19th in the NFL in yards gained last year and their 4.2 yards per carry ranked 15th. That’s not good enough for a team that is as unsettled as the Redskins are at quarterback. Whether it’s Robert Griffin III behind center or Kirk Cousins or Colt McCoy, the QB will benefit greatly…

  20. Need to Know: Two to watch during Redskins rookie camp

    May 13, 2015, 5:10 AM EDT

    Trey-Williams-2

    Here is what you need to know on this Wednesday, May 13, 78 days before the Washington Redskins open training camp in Richmond, VA. Nickel coverage Five thoughts about the buzz around the Redskins. —It looks like the Redskins and the agents for both Ryan Kerrigan and Trent Williams are moving towards contract extensions for…

RealRedskins.com Archives

Follow Us On Twitter