Skip to content

Portis: No News is Good News

Sep 4, 2006, 1:58 PM EDT

Comments Off on Portis: No News is Good News

Tandler’s Redskins Blog Ver. 09.04.06–We will get our first official peek at the condition of Clinton Portis’ left shoulder sometime in the next few days when the Redskins release the injury report for Monday night’s game against the Minnesota Vikings. It will be good to get some clarity in a situation where that has been a rare commodity.

You can reach Rich Tandler by email at

Some sloppy reporting over the weekend has led many to conclude that the chances are slim that Portis will take the field on Monday. A report on, which is a popular website that compiles sports reports from around the Internet and posts them in capsule form, said that Portis was “doubtful” for the opener. Here is the report:

Redskins | Portis doubtful for opener
Sat, 2 Sep 2006 09:16:01 -0700

The Associated Press reports Washington Redskins RB Clinton Portis‘ (shoulder) availability for the season opener is in serious doubt, according to head coach Joe Gibbs.

This led to a rash of message board posts and talk-show calls from panicked Redskins fans saying that, see, the injury really is more serious than the Redskins are letting on. The problem is that Joe Gibbs never said any such thing. The last time he spoke to the media, which was on Friday, here is what he had to say about the injury situation:

With the exception of Clinton and Shawn, I think we know what we’ve got with everyone else (in terms of injuries). I think Clinton has done extremely well. We’ll have a discussion with him and see what he thinks.

How they get “serious doubt” out of this statement, I have no idea. The folks at KFFL should know that the word “doubtful” has a very precise meaning in terms of NFL injuries. On the official injury report it means that there is a 75% chance that the player won’t play. You simply can’t draw that conclusion from what Gibbs said. It was quite sloppy and irresponsible of KFFL to have stated the situation in that way.

The view here is that it would be surprising, although not shocking, for Portis to sit out on Monday. This feeling is based on the simple fact that if the shoulder was considerably worse than the Redskins have been indicating that word of that would have leaked out by now. This story is national news. It is being pounded on all angles. The health of Portis’ shoulder is a critical story in the fantasy football world. Ever since the injury happened on August 13 thousands of phone calls have been made in an effort to get a solid nugget of information indicating that the injury would either cost Portis some games or would seriously hamper his performance in 2006. Not one remotely credible report has come out indicating that either one of those is likely to happen.

In this case, the old saying rings very true—no news is good news.

This doesn’t mean that there is no cause for concern. Although Portis is right handed and he prefers to carry the ball in that hand and the injury is to the left shoulder, consider the picture below.

He’s using his left arm to push off a defender and gain a few additional yards. If the arm you use for your stiff arm is stiff all season long, that could well to hamper your effectiveness, especially if defenders are coaches to grab that arm and yank on it. Yeah, that wouldn’t really seem to be sporting, but don’t think that Gregg Williams would hesitate to do the same thing if he was an opposing defensive coordinator and he knew that a well-timed yank might put the other team’s best offensive player on the bench.

Regardless, it’s been amusing to see many Redskins-bashing members of the media do such an abrupt about-face when it comes to the value of Clinton Portis. When the Redskins traded for Portis in 2004 these folks were incredulous that they would give up Champ Bailey and a #2 draft pick for a system back. When they signed Portis to a big contract extension a few months later, it was ridiculous to pay so much for a mere running back, a commodity that could be had for much, much less cap space.

Now that Portis may, just may, be affected by this shoulder injury the same journalists have dropped the Redskins from being a possible Super Bowl contender to a team that will be fortunate to finish around .500. His value is growing immeasurably in his absence. A little consistency would be nice, but why should these guys start now?

Rich Tandler is the author of The Redskins From A to Z, Volume 1: The Games. This unique book has an account of every game the Redskins played from when the moved to Washington for the 1937 season through 2001. For details and ordering information go to

  1. oneampoet - Sep 5, 2006 at 9:40 PM

    You should listen to the Friday newsconference again, what you have is a bit of a misquote as you are not including the first part of the sentence when Gibbs says that all the starting players are ready to go for week 1 except portis and springs…it also looks like it has been confirmed today that Portis is questionable.

  2. Rich Tandler - Sep 6, 2006 at 3:29 AM

    No, he said that they had a good idea about all of the injured players except for Ports and Springs. He didn’t say that they wouldn’t be ready to do, he said that those were the two that he wasn’t sure of.

    The injury report is not out as of yet, so there is no confirmation that Portis is anything. And remember that “questionable” means its 50-50 that the player will play.

    The “doubtful” tag by KFFL was still an irresponsible headline.

  3. Joe - Sep 6, 2006 at 3:17 PM

    ESPN and everyone else seem to be running with the “doubtful” tag. Rich is right, there’s nothing official yet.

    I bet Gibbs plays this one close to the vest and calls him “questionable” or “day-to-day” on Thursday. Bad news for people have him on their fantasy teams.

  4. oneampoet - Sep 8, 2006 at 4:30 PM

    Portis out…guess everyone else had it right!

  5. Jerrard - Sep 8, 2006 at 7:13 PM

    I doubt that Portis plays on Monday. We should be ok with Betts and Duckett carrying the rock.

  6. Anonymous - Sep 10, 2006 at 3:10 AM

    Now Portis is in…maybe.
    No one should give too much credence to any report. It also shows no coach wants to show his hand before he has to.

    Oneampoet, why so accusatory? Archives

Follow Us On Twitter